Questions 1, October 23

[carson]

1. We, as a people, are not always responsible for our own beliefs and behaviors. From being conceived to the latter stages of our lives, we aren't completely responsible for what actions we commit or beliefs we have. For example, in the womb, babies don't consciously think about shifting positions or kicking, they just do it. These actions are a part of our development allowing us to develop mentally and physically before we are birthed. Furthermore, young children tend to adapt the religious beliefs of their parents. This isn't because of their deep understanding of faith, but rather due to learning and observing, which at the time we have little choice in doing. However, there are people who may be as old as adults who cannot be responsible for their behaviors or beliefs. This is most commonly due to neurological disorders such as Tourette syndrome. Tourette syndrome involves unusual repetitive movements or unwanted sounds that cannot be controlled. Another example is Alzheimer's disease. This horrible condition causes short term and eventually long term memory loss. More symptoms include confusion, irritability, aggression, mood swings, and many more that the afflicted person cannot control. The development of Perry Smith was greatly effected by nurture, as his lonely and disconnected state disallowed him to develop key social ideas that change ones outlook on life.

[evanrichardson]

I agree with a large portion of what you said about the effects of nurture on our behavioral patterns. However, I disagree with your opinion that nurture is the more important of the two. I feel that it is our nature that most greatly affects us. I believe that it is our nature that will determine how we as people ultimately turn out. It is nature that provides our foundation and nurture simply shapes the general path we will take. Our basic abilities are determined by nature and nurture dictates the range of our ability.