|
Post by justingoshorn on Oct 24, 2014 0:13:43 GMT
"When are we not responsible for our own beliefs or behaviors?" Never. no matter what the circumstances are, our behaviors are "our own behaviors," and because they are "our own," we must take full responsibility for them. When Perry was suspected or murder, the courts did not state "Because Perry lived a hard childhood, we do not believe he is at fault so we here by find him innocent." On the contrary, they recognized that the final decision to pull the trigger and murder members of the Clutter family was solely Perry's decision. To state that he is not responsible because he lived a rough life is asinine and only a valid argument if someone placed a finger over his and pulled the trigger against his will. When you dwell into it you realize that this is a childish argument, and it parallels the argument of " nuh uh, it was his fault!" An argument made in an effort to place the responsibility of one's actions on another. An argument that full grown adults still use to this day. Accepting responsibility for your actions is often a difficult thing to do, so people search for that easier way out, blaming someone else. By doing this, they demonstrate immaturity and incompetence to accept their own actions.
|
|
ethan
New Member
Posts: 8
|
Post by ethan on Oct 24, 2014 1:30:41 GMT
I agree for the most part of Justin's response, but do disagree on some level. As we develop from a child it takes time for us to learn the difference from right and wrong behaviors, nor do we have much, if any control over our actions as an infant. And on the opposite end of life, many of the elderly can suffer from diseases such as dementia and alzheimer's which prohibits them to engage in the world around them and deteriorates the mind leaving many unable to control many behaviors. However, I do agree that the main course of our life, we maintain full control of our mind, leaving us the ability us to control our own actions. While Perry suffered the constant abuse and anguish from his childhood, he was fully aware of his wrongful action in fulfilling the murder of the Clutter family and was rightfully accountable for this action leading to his execution in prison. The premeditated thought of any action holds us responsible to that action and consequence.
|
|